Comments on: Hitohira - 07 http://xebek.animeblogger.net/2007/07/09/hitohira-07/ Useless ramblings of an insane maniac Mon, 01 Dec 2008 17:47:28 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.2.3 By: Xebek http://xebek.animeblogger.net/2007/07/09/hitohira-07/#comment-37558 Xebek Tue, 10 Jul 2007 18:50:24 +0000 http://xebek.animeblogger.net/2007/07/09/hitohira-07/#comment-37558 I understand that Nono has a say and that its probably a better choice for her to do what she's doing. However Mirei isn't really in the wrong either because she's jut being concerned for her. Not saying either one is being unreasonable, just hat they showed that Mirei isn't being mean, she's just concerned whether. Whether its a right choice in the end for her to perform it doesn't really matter its still not really wrong of Mirei to be concerned. It's not so much her not saying anything becasue she's a doctor or not, she's just being concerned because it was a fact that the doctor said if she keeps using her voice too much she'll loose it. I don't think Mirei is in the wrong at all to try and push what she thinks. Its Nono's decision but I understand fully where Mirei is coming from, just trying to push someone who is stubborn in order to protect her health. So really, yes it is Nono's final decision and her choice to continue acting is probably the best one but its not wrong for Nono to care and fear for her friends safety. I understand that Nono has a say and that its probably a better choice for her to do what she’s doing. However Mirei isn’t really in the wrong either because she’s jut being concerned for her. Not saying either one is being unreasonable, just hat they showed that Mirei isn’t being mean, she’s just concerned whether. Whether its a right choice in the end for her to perform it doesn’t really matter its still not really wrong of Mirei to be concerned.

It’s not so much her not saying anything becasue she’s a doctor or not, she’s just being concerned because it was a fact that the doctor said if she keeps using her voice too much she’ll loose it. I don’t think Mirei is in the wrong at all to try and push what she thinks. Its Nono’s decision but I understand fully where Mirei is coming from, just trying to push someone who is stubborn in order to protect her health.

So really, yes it is Nono’s final decision and her choice to continue acting is probably the best one but its not wrong for Nono to care and fear for her friends safety.

]]> By: Kabitzin http://xebek.animeblogger.net/2007/07/09/hitohira-07/#comment-37552 Kabitzin Tue, 10 Jul 2007 18:09:50 +0000 http://xebek.animeblogger.net/2007/07/09/hitohira-07/#comment-37552 <blockquote>If anything, it made me kind of mad at Nono, because Mirei was doing what she thought was best for her and it does seem as if Nono is acting rather rashly. </blockquote> While I can understand Mirei's fear, it really isn't her place to be telling Nono what to do; Mirei is not a doctor, and Nono has the final say over her own body. Also, it is not explicitly stated that Nono will definitely lose her voice from doing stage drama. There are a number of outcomes: Nono does drama, and loses her voice from it. Nono does drama, and doesn't lose her voice. Nono doesn't do drama, but loses her voice anyway. Nono doesn't do drama, and doesn't lose her voice. With choices 1 and 2, Nono does what she loves, and either gets to continue doing it or doesn't. With choices 3 and 4, Nono doesn't do what she loves, and may or may not lose her voice anyway. So unless it is proven that Nono will be cured if and only if she quits acting, Nono's decision to continue acting is reasonable. When you consider the posibility that Nono could still lose her voice without acting (e.g. just engaging in a shouting match), the decision makes even more sense.

If anything, it made me kind of mad at Nono, because Mirei was doing what she thought was best for her and it does seem as if Nono is acting rather rashly.

While I can understand Mirei’s fear, it really isn’t her place to be telling Nono what to do; Mirei is not a doctor, and Nono has the final say over her own body. Also, it is not explicitly stated that Nono will definitely lose her voice from doing stage drama. There are a number of outcomes:

Nono does drama, and loses her voice from it.
Nono does drama, and doesn’t lose her voice.
Nono doesn’t do drama, but loses her voice anyway.
Nono doesn’t do drama, and doesn’t lose her voice.

With choices 1 and 2, Nono does what she loves, and either gets to continue doing it or doesn’t. With choices 3 and 4, Nono doesn’t do what she loves, and may or may not lose her voice anyway. So unless it is proven that Nono will be cured if and only if she quits acting, Nono’s decision to continue acting is reasonable. When you consider the posibility that Nono could still lose her voice without acting (e.g. just engaging in a shouting match), the decision makes even more sense.

]]>